BULLETIN 7 FINAL BULLETIN: ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY.
Saying No! to the Council Staff’s CWG options paper is not saying no to the evidenced based options available for Moreland.
Since the SMBL campaign began, the issue of bluestones as the most environmentally friendly surface for our lanes has received wide community and expert support. Typical was one of our first letters in June 2012 from the Merri Creek Management Committee who expressed concern about the impact of storm water run off from the non permeable concreted surface into our drains through the Merri Creek with the resultant build up of e coli and destruction of plant, insect and animal life. This view is also supported by Environmental Scientist Rob Catchglove in his paper pithily entitled “Water sensitive urban design and laneways: the 210 million litre question” in which he argued that the environmental benefits of a traditionally laid bluestone laneway… is its ability to infiltrate water and prevent runoff (and associated pollution) from going into local creeks and bays”.
Another issue raised by community and expert opinion has been the carbon content of concrete vs bluestone/sand – the components of the traditional approach to laying of the bluestone lanes. Dr. Enda Crossin, Program Director of the RMIT Centre for Design within the School of Architecture wrote to us that “If the bluestones were cut over 100 years ago, then the greenhouse emissions of their production is effectively zero…(whilst) “with sand you are looking at a greenhouse impact of about 8 kg CO2-eq per cubic meter”. This he compared with “low-strength concrete (say 25MPa)… (with ) greenhouse impacts (of) about 275 kg CO2-eq per cubic meter”. He gave as the source of his calculations as the Australasian Unit Process Life Cycle Inventory, assessed using IPCC 2007 factors.
One of the issues which obscued clear analysis in the debate was Council staff’s persistence in comparing concreting with their preferred alternative of embedding our bluestones in concrete underpinned by a drainage system. Of course, there would be little difference in environmental impact between the two! This latter option has never been SMBL’s choice and as we have argued in previous bulletins is no longer supported by international evidence based practice.
So now we come to the choice of the three options within the Options Paper.
Option 1: Retain the current policy. Reconstruct bluestone laneways in bluestone only in or abutting heritage areas, and replace with concrete everywhere else.
Clearly this is rejected on heritage, cultural significance and cost grounds.
Option 2 Retain bluestone laneways in heritage areas PLUS retain some additional bluestone laneways in the non-heritage areas using an assessment tool based on the example provided by Councils recently appointed Heritage advisor.
Equally this option is to be rejected on heritage grounds found in Article 6 of the Burra Charter as already stated. This option clearly demonstrates a lack of commitment to the integrity of the network of lanes as whole, to traditional laying of stones, and to sustainable and water sensitive design.
Option 3 Retain all bluestone laneways in all parts of the City.
Within the paper this option also has the following small print:
“Under this option, all bluestone laneways would be reconstructed in bluestone regardless of their location or condition. This option prioritises the heritage value over accessibility and other factors by preserving the highest amount of bluestone in the city and from an urban character perspective retains the most complete network of bluestone laneways. This is the most costly option, and potentially displaces other works, or slows down the laneway reconstruction program”.
This option is also rejected. We take exception to Council staff putting words in our mouth that SMBL “prioritises heritage value over accessibility”. We care deeply about social accessibility and issues of social connection for all within our community of Moreland. We join with Dr Michael Marmot, renowned World Health Organisation medical scientist and health promotion expert who argued that people’s lifestyles and the conditions in which they live and work strongly influence their social and physical health and that cultural interconnectedness is a key influence on the social determinants of the health of a community. In addition, we strongly urge Council to consider not only the social, environmental and cultural significance of our bluestone lanes but also their potential for the creation of a long term niche industry based on our harnessing of world’s best practice in conservation and preservation through their protection.